Is Optic Nerve Fibre Mis-Routing a Feature of Congenital Stationary Night Blindness?

Abstract

To determine whether patients with congenital stationary night blindness (CSNB) have electrophysiological evidence of optic nerve fibre mis-routing similar to that found in patients with ocular albinism (OA). We recorded the Pattern Onset VEP using a protocol optimised to detect mis-routing of optic nerve fibres in older children and adults. We tested 20 patients (age 15-69 yrs) with X-linked or autosomal recessive CSNB, 14 patients (age 9-56 yrs) with OA and 13 normally pigmented volunteers (age 21-66 yrs). We measured the amplitude and latency of the CI component at the occipital midline and over left and right occipital hemispheres. We also assessed the computed inter-hemispheric "difference" signal. Subjects with CSNB were classified as having the "complete" or "incomplete" phenotype on the basis of their ERG characteristics. Members of X-linked CSNB pedigrees underwent mutation screening of the NYX and CACNA1F genes. CI was significantly smaller over the ipsilateral hemisphere and more prominent over the contralateral hemisphere in OA patients compared with both controls and CSNB patients. In CSNB patients CI response amplitudes were not significantly different from controls but peak latency was prolonged at all three electrodes compared with controls. The inter-hemispheric "difference" signal was abnormal for the OA group but not for the CSNB group. Contralateral dominance of CI could be identified in the majority of OA patients and the "difference" signal was opposite in polarity for left compared with right eye stimulation in every patient in this group. Only 3 of 20 patients with CSNB showed significant inter-hemispheric asymmetry similar to that seen in the OA patients. All 3 CSNB patients with evidence for optic nerve fibre mis-routing had X-linked pedigrees: 2 had an identified mutation in the NYX gene but no mutation in either the NYX or CACNA1F genes was identified in the third. VEP evidence of optic nerve fibre mis-routing was present in 3 of the 11 subjects with "complete" phenotype and none of the 9 patients with "incomplete" phenotype CSNB. Mis-routing of optic nerve fibres does occur in CSNB but we found evidence of it in only 15% of our patients.