Is it a function? Generalizing from single- to multivariable settings

Abstract

Generalizing is a hallmark of mathematical thinking. The term ‘generalization’ is used to mean both the process of generalizing and the product of that process. This paper reports on five calculus students’ generalizing activity and what they generalized about multivariable functions. The study makes two contributions. The first is a fine-grained, actor-oriented characterization of the ways undergraduates generalized. This adds to knowledge in two areas: the use of the actor-oriented perspective and generalization in advanced mathematics. The second contribution is the products of students’ generalizing: what they generalized about what it means for a multivariable relation to represent a function). This adds to the literature about student reasoning regarding multivariable topics by characterizing the powerful ways of reasoning students possess pre-instruction.