Is closed diagnostic peritoneal lavage contraindicated in patients with previous abdominal surgery?

Abstract

To compare the accuracies and complication rates of diagnostic peritoneal lavage (DPL) in trauma patients with and without previous abdominal surgery. A retrospective review of DPL accuracy and complication rate was performed using all ED trauma patients who underwent DPL during 1993 as identified by the trauma registry. Care was provided at a Level-1 trauma center, a 1,100-bed, central-city teaching hospital with an annual ED census of 84,000. Records were reviewed for a history of previous surgery, DPL results, complications, mechanism of injury, and location of abdominal scars. DPL was performed using the Seldinger technique with a standard Arrow Diagnostic Peritoneal Lavage Kit using an 8-Fr catheter. Rates for patient groups with and without previous abdominal surgery were compared using Fisher's exact test. A "misclassified" DPL was defined as either a positive DPL with negative laparotomy or a negative DPL with subsequent need for laparotomy. "Complications" were defined as iatrogenic injury during the procedure or inability to obtain return of fluid during the lavage. A total of 372 DPLs were performed; 42 in patients with previous surgery and 330 in patients without prior surgery. The groups were similar with respect to proportion with blunt trauma (95% vs 97%), positive DPL (19% vs 19%), misclassified rate (2.4% vs 1.8%), and complication rate (2.4% vs 0.9%); no significant difference was found between groups. The previous abdominal surgeries were appendectomy (n = 20), tubal ligation (n = 5), abdominal hysterectomy (n = 4), cholecystectomy (nonlaparoscopic) (n = 4), pyloric stenosis (n = 1), uterine prolapse (n = 1), undescended testis (n = 1), partial gastrectomy (n = 1), and unknown (n = 5). The analysis had a 90% power of detecting a 10% difference between the 2 groups. The complication rate and accuracy of closed DPL in patients with previous abdominal surgery were similar to those for DPL performed in patients without previous abdominal surgery.