Is AI essential? Examining the need for deep learning in image-activated sorting of Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

Abstract

Artificial intelligence (AI) has become a focal point across a multitude of societal sectors, with science not being an exception. Particularly in the life sciences, imaging flow cytometry has increasingly integrated AI for automated management and categorization of extensive cell image data. However, the necessity of AI over traditional classification methods when extending imaging flow cytometry to include cell sorting remains uncertain, primarily due to the time constraints between image acquisition and sorting actuation. AI-enabled image-activated cell sorting (IACS) methods remain substantially limited, even as recent advancements in IACS have found success while largely relying on traditional feature gating strategies. Here we assess the necessity of AI for image classification in IACS by contrasting the performance of feature gating, classical machine learning (ML), and deep learning (DL) with convolutional neural networks (CNNs) in the differentiation of Saccharomyces cerevisiae mutant images. We show that classical ML could only yield a 2.8-fold enhancement in target enrichment capability, albeit at the cost of a 13.7-fold increase in processing time. Conversely, a CNN could offer an 11.0-fold improvement in enrichment capability at an 11.5-fold increase in processing time. We further executed IACS on mixed mutant populations and quantified target strain enrichment via downstream DNA sequencing to substantiate the applicability of DL for the proposed study. Our findings validate the feasibility and value of employing DL in IACS for morphology-based genetic screening of S. cerevisiae, encouraging its incorporation in future advancements of similar technologies.