(Invited) Challenges and Opportunities for the Computational Analysis of Electrochemical Energy Systems

Abstract

Electrochemical systems are challenging to analyze and design due to their multi-dimensional, time-dependent, and multi-physics nature. For this reason, many computational electrochemical system models have been developed in the past three decades, some of which can now be found in commercial software packages, e.g., COMSOL or ANSYS Fluent. These models however: i) are based on simplifying assumptions, e.g., reduced dimensionality, infinite dilution, Tafel kinetics; ii) contain uncertain input parameters, e.g., effective transport properties and kinetic parameters; and, iii) are only validated with a limited number of experiments, e.g., polarization curves. These limitations, understandable at the time due to limited computational resources, characterization techniques, and material understanding and stability, are difficult to justify today that parallel programming and computer clusters enable scientists to perform large multi-dimensional simulations; electrochemical testing has expanded to include segmented cell testing, impedance spectroscopy, water flux estimation, and in-operando visualization; and, characterization tools and techniques have been developed to, for example, easily measure adsorption isotherms, effective proton conductivity and, within a given resolution, visualize the three-dimensional microstructure of the electrodes.Scientists working on computational analysis of electrochemical systems must acknowledge that further model development is still needed and must take advantage of new resources to improve the robustness and accuracy of cell-level models. The path is long and crooked, but it is very likely that the opportunity for a truly useful computational model, one that can be used for design, is beyond simplistic implementations and polarization curves. The effort is great, but it can be minimized by concurrent software development, as well as, by careful experimental work dedicated to parameter estimation and model validation.This presentation aims at outlining the limitations of state-of-the-art models, the challenges and opportunities of concurrent development and maintenance of a multi-scale, transient electrochemical energy system software, such as the open-source fuel cell simulation toolbox (OpenFCST) [1], and the new opportunities provided by combining advanced characterization tools with computational analysis. As an example, the development and validation of the transient, two-phase fuel cell and electrolyzer cell-level models in OpenFCST will be discussed [2]. The use of a hydrogen-pump model to study the effect of an active catalyst in CL effective proton conductivity measurements will also be discussed as an example of concurrent experimental/model design [3].