Investigation of the UK37’ vs. SST relationship for Atlantic Ocean suspended particulate alkenones: An alternative regression model and discussion of possible sampling bias

Abstract

Alkenone unsaturation, expressed as the UK37’ index, is closely related to growth temperature of prymnesiophytes, thus providing a reliable proxy to infer past sea surface temperatures (SSTs). Here we address two lingering uncertainties related to this SST proxy. First, calibration models developed for core-top sediments and those developed for surface suspended particulates organic material (SPOM) show systematic offsets, raising concerns regarding the transfer of the primary signal into the sedimentary record. Second, questions remain regarding changes in slope of the UK37’ vs. growth temperature relationship at the temperature extremes. Based on (re)analysis of 31 new and 394 previously published SPOM UK37’ data from the Atlantic Ocean, a new regression model to relate UK37’ to SST is introduced; the Richards curve (Richards, 1959). This non-linear regression model provides a robust calibration of the UK37’ vs. SST relationship for Atlantic SPOM samples and uniquely accounts for both the fact that the UK37’ index is a proportion, and so must lie between 0 and 1, as well as for the observed reduction in slope at the warm and cold ends of the temperature range. As with prior fits of SPOM UK37’ vs. SST, the Richards model is offset from traditional regression models of sedimentary UK37’ vs. SST. We posit that (some of) this offset can be attributed to the seasonally and depth biased sampling of SPOM material.