Investigation of the Dayton, Ohio, IR 75 Sign Truss Failure of September 11, 2006

Abstract

On September 11, 2006, “unusual” deflections of an overhead bridge-mounted sign support truss along IR 75 in Dayton, Ohio were reported. Investigation by Ohio DOT road crews revealed the complete fracture of two truss members near one of the truss supports. While total collapse did not occur, such an event could have catastrophic consequences along a major arterial roadway like IR 75. This concern, along with the fact that a similar failure occurred near Cleveland, Ohio in 2004, prompted an investigation that is the subject of this manuscript. Results of the investigation are based upon a combination of in situ field monitoring of traffic-induced bridge vibrations at the location of the failed sign support truss, finite-element simulation of the expected dynamic response of the original truss in such an environment, the length of service of the truss at the time of its failure, the volume of truck traffic on the bridge in question during that time of service, and metallurgical examination of the failed co...