Investigating competitive interactions from spatial patterns of trees in multispecies boreal forests: the random mortality hypothesis revisited

Abstract

Plant competition is expected to produce an overdispersed spatial pattern relative to the initial pattern of individuals. The spatial patterns of two boreal forest tree species, Populus tremuloides Michx. (trembling aspen) and Pinus banksiana Lamb. (jack pine), were examined for evidence of intraspecific and interspecific competition. Data consisting of species, position, and age of tree stems were obtained from a 21-year-old, 40 m × 30 m postfire area of boreal forest in northern Alberta, Canada. Tree stems were mapped and classified according to size (greater or less than 5 cm in diameter at ground height) and species. A variation on the random mortality hypothesis was used to detect overdispersed patterns indicative of competitive interactions. This was done by comparing the size of neighbouring stems with those expected when the size or "success" of a stem occurred randomly. The results showed roughly two scales of pattern. First, large seed-regenerating jack pine neighboured each other more often than expected, but jack pine and trembling aspen neighboured each other less than expected. Second, although the large jack pine appeared to be clustered as neighbours, they tended to associate at distances farther than expected. These results show little evidence of density-dependence patterns in the species at the site, and the interspecific association between jack pine and trembling aspen could be indicative of a heterogeneous habitat.Key words: triangulation, size variability, Pinus banksiana, Populus tremuloides, jack pine, trembling aspen.