Intraspecific variation in spring leaf phenology and duration of leaf expansion in relation to leaf habit and leaf size of temperate tree species

Abstract

Spring leaf phenology has been intensively studied in temperate deciduous broad-leaved tree species, but the phenology of evergreen broad-leaved tree species has seldom been focused on. Evaluation of the difference in spring leaf phenology between coexisting deciduous and evergreen species is essential to predict their responses to climate change. In this study, spring leaf phenology was investigated for the 12 deciduous and 12 evergreen broad-leaved species coexisting in a warm-temperate forest in Japan, based on the predictions that selection pressure for earlier leaf production in spring results in less intraspecific variation in phenology at a given timing (SDmax) and a shorter duration of leaf expansion in deciduous than in evergreen species. In contrast to this prediction, SDmax did not differ between deciduous and evergreen species and was not related to leaf area or LMA. On the other hand, the duration of leaf expansion was longer in evergreen than in deciduous species, and was positively correlated with LMA. The leaves of greater LMA required longer periods of leaf expansion, probably due to a higher cost of and/or more conservative leaf development in the face of herbivory. As a consequence, the timing of full leaf expansion was delayed not only by later budburst (approximately two weeks) but also by a longer duration of leaf expansion (approximately two weeks) in evergreen than in deciduous broad-leaved species, which would probably influence the productivity of newly emerging leaves in spring.