Abstract

Trabecular structure is frequently used to differentiate between highly divergent mechanical environments. Less is known regarding the response of the structural properties to more subtle behavioral differences, as the range of intrapopulation variation in trabecular architecture is rarely studied. Examining the extent to which lower limb trabecular architecture varies when inferred mobility levels and environment are consistent between groups within a relatively homogenous population may aid in the contextualization of interpopulation differences, improve detectability of sexual dimorphism in trabecular structure, and improve our understanding of trabecular bone functional adaptation. The study sample was composed of adult individuals from three high/late medieval cemeteries from Cambridge (10th-16th c.), a hospital (n = 57), a parish cemetery (n = 44) and a friary (n = 14). Trabecular architecture was quantified in the epiphyses of the femur and tibia, using high resolution computed tomography. The parish individuals had the lowest bone volume fraction and trabecular thickness in most regions. Multiple sex differences were observed, but the patterns were not consistent across volumes of interest. Differences between the three groups highlight the great variability of trabecular bone architecture, even within a single sedentary population. This indicates that trabecular bone may be used in interpreting subtle behavioral differences, and suggests that multiple archaeological sites need to be studied to characterize structural variation on a population level. Variation in sex and group differences across anatomical locations further demonstrates the site-specificity in trabecular bone functional adaptation, which might explain why little consistent sexual dimorphism has been reported previously.

Highlights

  • Demonstrable structural differences in trabecular bone exist between species as well as between populations within a species (Christen, Ito, Galis, & van Rietbergen, 2015; Ryan & Ketcham, 2002b, 2005; Ryan & Shaw, 2012, 2015; Saers, Cazorla-Bak, Shaw, Stock, & Ryan, 2016; Saers, Ryan, & Stock, 2019b)

  • The complexity of bone functional adaptation and the multitude of factors contributing to trabecular morphology are widely acknowledged (Kivell, 2016, Saers et al, 2019b), structural differences in lower limb trabecular bone between broad categories of subsistence-related mobility suggest that subsistence behavior is a key determinant of overall habitual loading and potentially a major driver of lower limb trabecular variation in humans (Chirchir, Ruff, Junno, & Potts, 2017; Doershuk et al, 2019; Saers et al, 2016; Saers et al, 2019b)

  • Our study examined whether groups within a sedentary population differ in the structural properties of the lower limb

Read more

Summary

Introduction

Demonstrable structural differences in trabecular bone exist between species as well as between populations within a species (Christen, Ito, Galis, & van Rietbergen, 2015; Ryan & Ketcham, 2002b, 2005; Ryan & Shaw, 2012, 2015; Saers, Cazorla-Bak, Shaw, Stock, & Ryan, 2016; Saers, Ryan, & Stock, 2019b). The complexity of bone functional adaptation and the multitude of factors contributing to trabecular morphology are widely acknowledged (Kivell, 2016, Saers et al, 2019b), structural differences in lower limb trabecular bone between broad categories of subsistence-related mobility suggest that subsistence behavior is a key determinant of overall habitual loading and potentially a major driver of lower limb trabecular variation in humans (Chirchir, Ruff, Junno, & Potts, 2017; Doershuk et al, 2019; Saers et al, 2016; Saers et al, 2019b) This idea is strengthened by a lack of differences found when inferred levels of mobility are similar between populations (Chirchir et al, 2017; Doershuk et al, 2019).

Objectives
Methods
Findings
Discussion
Conclusion
Full Text
Published version (Free)

Talk to us

Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have

Schedule a call