Intra-operative irradiation (IORT) for primary advanced and recurrent rectal cancer: a need for randomised studies

Abstract

The aim of this study was to determine the impact of intra-operative irradiation (IORT) combined with pre-operative external beam irradiation (EBRT) and surgical resection in patients with locally advanced primary or recurrent rectal cancer. 64 patients with locally advanced primary cancer and 104 with recurrence had EBRT (46–50 Gy) before surgery. 80 patients received IORT (median dose 15 Gy energy 12 MeV). 80 patients had R0 resections, 47 R1 and 41 R2 resections. More R1 resections were performed in the IORT group, more R0 and R2 resections in the non-IORT group. Median follow-up was around 22 months. 146 patients were resected, 22 had exploratory laparotomy. The cumulative overall survival was similar for both the IORT and non-IORT groups. 5-year survival for primary cancers was 48% versus 28% for recurrences. No R2 resections survived 3.5 years. 5-year-survival for R0 resections was nearly 60% and around 30% for R1 resections. The survival curves of the patients given and not given IORT treatment was not statistically different when R0, R1 and R2 resections were analysed separately. IORT did not seem to influence the local recurrence rate when R0 and R1 resections were analysed separately or in a multivariate analysis. The IORT and non-IORT groups were not identical with regard to type of cancer and R-stage. Still the lack of an identifiable impact of IORT suggests that there is a need for randomised studies of the IORT effect.