Intraobserver repeatability for a standardized protocol to quantify keel bone damage in laying hens using discrete and continuous radiographic measures.

Abstract

Sternal carina damage (keel bone damage, KBD) is an important welfare concern for laying hen producers and backyard flock owners. Quantitative radiographic measures of KBD severity are helpful for researchers who study causes for this problem and the effects of novel interventions. The objectives of the current retrospective secondary analysis study were to develop and test intraobserver repeatability for a standardized protocol to quantify three categories of radiographic KBD using open-source image analysis software and discrete and continuous variables. The standardized protocol was developed and evaluated using triplicate measurements of 470 keel bone radiographs that had been previously acquired for a prospective study. Intraobserver repeatability was assessed using intra-class correlation coefficient (ICC) and control chart methods. Based on control chart analyses, measures within the acceptable range of intra-observer variation using the standardized protocol were the number of complete cranial fractures (97.02%), incomplete cranial fractures (96.38%), complete caudal fractures (95.32%), incomplete caudal fractures (98.09%), cranial calluses (99.79%), and caudal calluses (98.09%); proportion of deviation (POD) measurements (97.87%); and angle of displacement (AOD) measurements (93.60%). Findings can be used as background to support future research studies on KBD in laying hens.