Intra- and inter-rater reliability of muscle and fat thickness measurements obtained using portable ultrasonography in older adults

Abstract

Ultrasonography (US) is a promising tool for assessing body composition, offering accuracy and accessibility. However, technician skills and equipment characteristics can impact measurement reliability. We aimed to evaluate the intra- and inter-rater reliability of two evaluators using A-mode Portable Ultrasound to measure muscle and fat thickness in Brazilian older adults. Quantitative cross-sectional study carried out with 150 community-dwelling older adults of Campinas-SP-Brazil, recruited in a retirement preparation program and a geriatric outpatient care unit. Scans of nine anatomical points were performed using the portable ultrasound in A-mode (BodyMetrix Pro System BX2000; Livermore, CA), with 6 scans per location and 3 measurements taken by each evaluator. After the selection and analysis of the generated images, muscle and fat thickness were measured. Reliability estimates between measures of the same evaluator (intra-rater) and between evaluators (inter-rater) were assessed using intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC), and differences within and between technicians were assessed using one-way ANOVA. Analyses were carried out for the overall sample and stratified by sex and by nutritional status. Excellent ICC values (>0.90) were found for subcutaneous fat thickness in intra- and inter-rater reliability analyses. The lowest ICC values were observed for deep abdominal fat thickness measured by evaluator 1 (ICC=0.90) and evaluator 2 (ICC=0.87), as well as in the inter-rater analysis (ICC=0.85). Muscle thickness measurements had satisfactory ICC values for triceps, biceps, anterior thigh, and calf, ranging from moderate to good (ICC 0.50-0.90). A portable A-mode ultrasound demonstrates excellent reliability among both intra- and inter-raters for assessing fat thickness but only moderate for muscle thickness in older adults. Hence, this could prompt inquiries regarding the sole reliance on this tool for quantifying muscle mass and examining sarcopenia in older adults. To our knowledge, this study represents the first assessment of reliability for a portable A-mode ultrasound device conducted with older adults.