Interpopulation Differences in Shoaling Behaviour in Guppies (Poecilia reticulata): Roles of Social Environment and Population Origin

Abstract

In Trinidad, guppies (Poecilia reticulata) in high-predation localities show more cohesive shoaling behaviour than those living with less dangerous predators in low-predation sites. We evaluated the relative contributions of population origin (i.e. genetic and/or maternal effects) and social environment on the expression of shoaling by assessing the behaviour of juveniles reared in a range of social conditions. Focal individuals, offspring of guppies from populations from high- or low-predation localities, were reared in a multifactorial experiment; we created four different social conditions by manipulating the source and demography of the conspecific residents with whom focal individuals interacted. We found that high-predation fish displayed a stronger propensity to shoal than low-predation ones. Our results also suggest a role for interactions between the source of the focal individuals, the demography of the group in which they were reared and the origin of the guppies with whom they were reared. Depending on their origin (high- vs. low- predation) and rearing density, our focal fish were more likely to shoal if they were reared with high-predation residents. Learning from high-predation residents, aggressive interactions with low-predation residents and/or phenotype matching could have played a role in driving this effect of social environment. This effect of the phenotype of conspecifics on shoaling development would enhance heritable differences in shoaling propensity such that both could contribute to the well-documented difference in shoaling behaviour of high- and low-predation guppies in natural populations.