Interobserver variability in MRI measurements of mesorectal invasion depth in rectal cancer.

Abstract

To assess the interobserver variability in MRI measurements of mesorectal invasion depth (MID) in rectal adenocarcinomas primarily staged as T3, by determining the level of interobserver agreement in the differentiation of individual T3 substages and of T3a-b vs. T3c-d disease, between readers with different levels of expertise. A retrospective analysis of 60 patients classified by MRI as having T3 rectal cancers was performed. Each patient underwent MR examination in a 1.5T machine and the standard imaging protocol included a high-resolution axial T2-weighted sequence in which the measurements were determined by independent radiologists (readers A and B, with 15years and 1year of experience, respectively). The rectum was further divided into quadrants and each reader selected the quadrant where the measurement was taken. The patients were grouped according to the MID (T3a < 1mm; T3b 1-5mm; T3c > 5-15mm; T3d > 15mm) and the interobserver reliability was tested using Cohen's kappa. Population included 40 males and 20 females with a median age of 65.9years. Interobserver agreement on individual substage differentiation (T3 a, b, c and d) was moderate (K = 0.428) and in the quadrant evaluation the level of agreement was also moderate (K = 0.414). Nevertheless, the interobserver reliability for the differentiation between stages T3a-b vs. T3c-d was substantial (K = 0.697). There is no considerable interobserver variability when distinguishing T3a-b from T3c-d tumors, regardless of the quadrant where the MID is measured. Therefore, assessment of MID, for that purpose, is a reproducible MR parameter, irrespectively of the readers' experience.