Interobserver variability in assessments of atherosclerotic lesion type via optical frequency domain imaging

Abstract

BackgroundTo date, there have been no data available regarding the diagnostic performance of optical frequency domain imaging (OFDI) for in vivo histological classification of atherosclerotic lesions. This study investigated whether OFDI can be used to diagnose and classify histological atherosclerotic lesions in the coronary artery by ex vivo histological examinations. MethodsThree-hundred-fifteen histological cross-sections from 21 autopsy hearts were matched with the OFDI images. Histological cross-sections were classified into six categories: adaptive intimal thickening (AIT), pathological intimal thickening (PIT), fibrous cap atheroma (FA), fibrocalcific plaque (FC), calcified nodule, and healed erosion/rupture. The five observers with different years of experience in the interpretation of OFDI provided a single diagnosis for the OFDI scans of each cross-section according to the aforementioned six histological categories. The diagnostic accuracy and interobserver variability of lesion types for each OFDI observer were determined using histology as the gold standard. ResultsThe overall agreement rates between OFDI and histopathologic diagnosis for OFDI observers 1–5 were 81%, 70%, 68%, 61%, and 50% (κ values of 0.75, 0.61, 0.58, 0.49, and 0.36), respectively. Although the diagnostic accuracy of OFDI for detecting AIT and FC was excellent for all five observers, the sensitivity, and positive predictive values of OFDI for detecting PIT and FA were low in proportion to years of experience. ConclusionThe diagnostic accuracy of atherosclerotic tissue properties from OFDI scans correlated with the observers' years of experience, especially when lesions contained lipid components.