Interactive effects of episodic hypoxia and cannibalism on juvenile blue crab mortality

Abstract

We hypothesized that as the spatial extent of hypoxic bottom water increased, (1) adult blue crab predator densities would increase in shallow habitats as they avoided hypoxia, and that (2) juvenile blue crabs, which use shallow unvegetated habitat as a predation refuge from adult conspecifics, would experience increased mortality rates during crowding by cannibalistic adult blue crabs. These hypotheses were tested along a depth gradient of sandy-mud shoreline in the Neuse River Estuary (NRE), North Carolina, USA using a combination of (1) hydrographic measurements to characterize the spatial extent of hypoxia, (2) beach seines to quantify the density of adult blue crab predators in relatively shallow water as a function of 1, and (3) tethering experiments to quantify relative rates of predation on juvenile blue crabs as a function of 1 and 2. During our seven tethering experiments, the NRE study site experienced a range of DO scenarios including normoxia, chronic hypoxia, and hypoxic upwelling. No known predators of juvenile blue crabs, other than adult conspecifics, were collected in any of our shallow-water seines. During the transition from normoxia to chronic hypoxia, blue crab predator densities in shallow refuge habitats increased 4-fold, and relative mortality rates of juvenile blue crabs in shallow habitats increased exponentially with the density of adult conspecifics. Conversely, during hypoxic upwelling events, the density of adult blue crabs in shallow water declined, which may explain why the relative mortality of juvenile crabs did not increase significantly with the increasing spatial extent of hypoxia. Thus, juvenile blue crabs may be relatively safe from adult conspecifics during hypoxic upwelling events, but not during chronic hypoxia. These experimental results highlight the need to consider the effects of dynamic water quality on mobile consumers emigrating from degraded habitats when considering indirect trophic impacts beyond the immediate area of impact.