Integration of Twelve Step with Evidence-Based Practices in a Residential Treatment Center

Abstract

Background: Residential treatment for substance use disorders (SUDs) typically involves both medical and psychological treatments to best meet the needs of service users. Common treatments include Twelve Step Facilitation (TSF) as well as evidence-based practices (EBPs) such as cognitive behavioral therapies and medications. Researchers have discussed the difficulties with implementation and sustainability of EBPs within treatment centers that predominantly use TSF. Objectives: Understanding the process of implementation is an important area of study to inform future implementation efforts. The present study involved a qualitative investigation of a residential treatment center that integrated EBPs alongside TSF. Treatment stakeholders (N=22) were interviewed about their experience with integration. Results: The results indicated that the organization’s evolution to integrate evidence-based practices (e.g., medication, evidenced-based psychotherapy) occurred through a process of themes including staff members’ personal allegiance to Twelve Step; tension among staff members; staff collaboration; and integration of theoretical orientations. The results parallel those found in the Normalization Process Theory of implementation. Conclusions: The present study provides an understanding as to how Twelve Step and EBPs can be integrated into a residential treatment center, allowing for service users to have choice in their care. The program’s ability to navigate the treatment evolution can be used as an example for integrating evidence-based practice with Twelve Step to meet the many needs of individuals seeking substance use treatment.