Integration of On-Premises and Cloud-Based Software: The Product Bundling Perspective

Abstract

Firms in the cloud-computing era are facing the critical issue of integrating on-premises software and cloud- based software services. To date, the software industry has designed two different types of integration methods—an enterprise service bus (ESB) and an integration platform as a service (iPaaS). However, there are conflicting views on when and how to use these different integration methods to fulfill integration needs. This study aims to resolve this confusion through economic modeling. By focusing on the indirect network effect and following a two-product bundling framework, we establish a stylized model to investigate the optimal pricing and bundling decisions and the best integration choice. Our findings contradict common perceptions that an iPaaS is the better choice for integration and show that firms can derive higher value by adopting ESB to integrate on-premises software and cloud-based software services. Conceptually, given that the overall network value received from a cloud-based software service is higher, the use of ESB can contribute toward significantly improving the total value of the two software applications. We also find that unbundling is the best marketing strategy for firms because software integration can improve the valuation of individual software. Our findings have important implications for software vendors. It suggests that vendors can leverage a higher network value from the software service by integrating it with on-premises software applications through ESB instead of iPaaS and eventually realize a higher profit by extracting more value from consumers. Since integration increases the value of individual products, the vendors must sell them separately instead of selling them as a bundle.