Integrated emergy and economic evaluation of a case tidal power plant in China

Abstract

Abstract Although endowed with abundant tidal resources, China's tidal power generation industry has been largely lagging behind other renewable energy alternatives such as small hydropower, photovoltaic power, wind power and biomass-based power. To probe the reasons behind this slow pace of development, an emergy evaluation and an economic analysis were conducted on the Jiangxia Tidal Power Station (JTPS), which has an installed capacity of 4.1 MW. The JTPS is the largest tidal power station in China and the fourth largest in the world. The evaluation results exhibited a total power conversion system emergy use of 1.59E+19 sej to generate 5.90E+13 J of electricity in 2014. Tidal energy only accounts for 16.54% of the total energy budget. The rest of the resources were invested to capture and convert tidal energy to electricity, thereby generating a relatively low efficiency or high transformity of 2.69E+05 sej/J. The results revealed a JTPS emergy loading ratio (ELR) and energy sustainability index (ESI) of 3.72 and 0.41, respectively, which indicates poorer environmental performance compared to other renewable energy power plants, with the exception of photovoltaic power. In addition, the economic analysis revealed a JTPS power generation cost of 2.41 CNY/kWh, which is even higher than that of concentrating solar power (CSP). The JTPS is less competitive because tidal energy has a lower quality and is more decentralized when generating electricity compared to other renewable resources. This inefficiency was exacerbated in the JTPS case due to the original multipurpose design and consequential poor site selection with respect to tidal electricity generation. These results further highlight the importance of dam site selection and the tidal range, as they are critical for the improvement of the tidal power generation environmental performance. More importantly, R&D is essential to promote the development of this technology and to ultimately utilize abundant tidal resources in an efficient and sustainable way.