Insights of smallholder farmers on the trade-offs of eucalyptus plantation

Abstract

Eucalyptus is a popular evergreen perennial tree that grows quickly. Due to its diverse economic value and wide range of adaptations, the eucalyptus is commonly grown in tropical and subtropical regions. Eucalyptus is an economically important tree. However, the economic importance of eucalyptus ensued at the expense of undesirable ecological consequences. This qualitative study reports the advantages and disadvantages of eucalyptus woodlot establishment on the productivity of arable and grazing lands. In this study, nine knowledgeable farmers were involved in an in-depth individual interview and four focus group discussions were conducted. Farmers have frequently reported the negative impact of eucalyptus plantations on the productivity of the agricultural system. Eucalyptus serves as a refuge for crop pests and pathogens such as aphids and rust. Besides, the shade suppresses the development of the understory and adjacent crops, pastures, fodder, and other species of native trees and shrubs if they are planted together. Eucalyptus has increasingly replaced eco-friendly native trees and shrubs traditionally used as hedges, windbreaks, fodder, shelters for domestic and wild animals, and enhancers of soil fertility. Besides deteriorating soil fertility, structure, and moisture, it drains wetlands, springs, and streams and reduces the flow of rivers. Nevertheless, farmers acknowledged the importance of eucalyptus as a construction material, a source of fuelwood and charcoal, and income. To make the best use of eucalyptus woodlots without imposing adverse effects on agroecology, farmers have suggested that plantation sites should be marginally suitable for crop and livestock production. The expanded plantation needs to be contracted by removing a significant proportion of the established eucalyptus woodlots. Plantations of eucalyptus around watering points should be discouraged. Fast-growing, resilient, and eco-friendly tree species, such as those from Grevillea and Populus species, and sibling (leguminous) trees and shrubs delivering comparable products and services should be sought after to replace the significant proportion of the established eucalyptus woodlot.