Insights Gained by Modeling the Kinetics of Archetypal Hydrogen Atom Transfer Reactions: NH3 + ·H ⇆ H2N· + H2 and CH4 + ·H ⇆ H3C· + H2

Abstract

ABSTRACTExperimental measurements of the kinetics of the title reactions extend to temperature ranges of 1360 K for the ammonia‐hydrogen reaction and of 1602 K for the methane‐hydrogen reaction. Curved plots of ln(k) versus 1/T are obtained. Many theoretical calculations modeling these reactions routinely use tunneling corrections to match experiment. The steepness and curvatures of the plots are modeled successfully in this work and are shown to be caused solely by changes in the bond dissociation energies of the bonds involved in the reactions without invoking tunneling or any other adjustable parameters. The conclusion that tunneling does not contribute significantly to the rates in the temperature range of the measurements is in stark contrast with those theoretical calculations invoking large tunneling factors in the experimental temperature range. Support for the conclusion is provided by theoretical calculations of harmonic quantum transition state theory implementing instanton theory. There is direct experimental evidence that significant tunneling occurs in some H atom transfers, as with isotopomers of H2 + ·H and other H transfers at very low temperatures. However, there is no direct experimental evidence of significant tunneling contributions to the rates of the title reactions in the temperature range of the measurements. Insights are gained into what specific forces must be overcome by the enthalpy of activation for reaction to occur.