Infrastructure- and workforce capacity for the provision of health care to people with invasive home mechanical ventilation: A scoping review of indicators and norms

Abstract

IntroductionBoth the availability and adequacy of infrastructure- and workforce capacity are critical to provide integrated and continuing care, especially to people with complex care needs such as those with invasive home mechanical ventilation (HMV). This review aims to synthesise indicators and norms that are available for assessing this infrastructure- and workforce capacity. MethodsA scoping review was conducted by searching PubMed, Livivo, the grey literature, specific registries, and the websites of relevant professional societies for international publications on specific infrastructure- and workforce capacity indicators or norms on HMV from January 2000 up to and including March 2021. Exclusion criteria comprised missing indicator/norm information, differing populations/care settings, and secondary literature. Indicators and norms were extracted, clustered, and analysed by applying the WHO Monitoring and Evaluation Framework and qualitative content analysis. ResultsFifteen publications met the inclusion criteria. Forty-five indicators and 44 norms on HMV-related infrastructure- and workforce capacity were synthesised. The synthesis revealed a heterogeneous set of indicators and norms (mainly from cross-sectional surveys and guidelines). The methodological information on their definition, rationales, disaggregation, and evidence is scarce. ConclusionTo enable integrated care in HMV and comparable populations with complex care needs, the identified limitations in assessing infrastructure- and workforce capacity should be addressed.