Informal and Formal Support Groups Retain Women and Minorities in Physics

Abstract

Ten U.S. minority female undergraduates who aspire to become physicists were followed over an 8‐year period. Participant observation and in‐depth interviews recorded the strategies they used to earn bachelor’s degrees in physics or physics‐related fields, and then go on to graduate school and/or careers in science. One significant strategy these women of color employed was participating in small subcommunities with other women or underrepresented ethnic minorities at the margins of their local physics community. The study found that informal peer groups offered safe spaces to counter negative experiences, to normalize their social realities, and to offer practical guidance for persevering in the field. Formal women‐ and minority‐serving programs in physics provided foundations for community building, stronger curriculum and instruction, networking, and role models. The positive effects of informal and formal support groups on these students’ experiences challenge a standard application of Pierre Bourdieu’s framework of social and cultural capital. Women of color in the study initially lacked traditional capital of “acceptable” appearance, cultural background and habits, and networks that are more easily acquired by white males and are rewarded by the U.S. physics culture. However, instead of failing or leaving, as Bourdieu’s theory would predict, the minority women persisted and achieved in science. The marginal communities contributed to their retention by offering safe spaces in which they could learn and share alternative ways of “accruing capital.” Moreover, as these women made strides along their academic and career paths, they also engaged in social justice work in efforts to change the physics culture to be more welcoming of nontraditional members. The outcomes of the study offer empirical confirmation of the critical need for informal and institutionally supported women’s and minorities’ support groups to promote diversity in science.