Influence of the mechanical properties of resilient denture liners on the retention of overdenture attachments

Abstract

Statement of problemInformation is lacking about the selection criteria for silicone resilient denture liners applied as a matrix material for attachments on overdentures. PurposeThe purpose of this in vitro study was to investigate the mechanical properties of silicone resilient denture liners and their influence on the initial retention force of overdenture attachments and the reduction in retention force over time. Material and methodsNine types of silicone resilient denture liner were injected and fixed to the matrix section of an experimental denture base. They were then fitted to an epoxy resin model that simulated the residual ridge with a patrix ball attachment (n=10). The retention force of the denture was measured with a digital force gauge, and the maximum force of traction (N) was regarded as the initial retention force. The retention force reduction (N) after repeated insertion and removal (n=5) was calculated by subtracting the retention force after 3348 cycles (3-year simulated insertion and removal) from the initial retention force. The intaglio of the matrix was observed with a scanning electron microscope (SEM) before and after the 3348 cycles. Four mechanical properties (hardness, strain-in-compression, tensile strength, and arithmetic mean roughness) of the resilient denture liners were measured. One-way ANOVA of the initial retention force of each lining material was performed, followed by the Scheffe test (α=.05). Pearson correlation analysis was used (α=.05) to analyze correlations of the initial retention force with the retention force reduction after insertion and removal and the mechanical properties of each material. Multiple regression analysis with the stepwise method extracted the initial retention force and the retention force reduction as dependent variables, and the resilient denture liner mechanical properties as explanatory variables (α=.05). ResultsThe initial retention force of the resilient denture liners was 1.3 to 5.4 N. Multiple comparisons showed significant differences in some groups (P<.05). The retention force reduction of the resilient denture liners was 0.2 to 1.9 N. Multiple regression analysis with the stepwise method extracted hardness and strain-in-compression as explanatory variables for the initial retention force and the retention force reduction. ConclusionsWithin the limitations of this in vitro study, hardness was found to influence the initial retention force of the overdenture, and strain-in-compression influenced the retention force reduction in the 3-year simulation.