Influence of the choice of stream temperature model on the projections of water temperature in rivers

Abstract

In the majority of studies aiming at stream temperature warming due to climate change just a single water temperature model is used. Choosing a single model may highly impact the conclusions from the study. In this paper four relatively different empirical or semi-empirical models: perceptron neural networks, product unit networks, extended logistic regression and air2stream were applied to project the impact of climate change on water temperature in rivers located in temperate climatic zones of the USA and Poland. The models were driven by daily air temperature and streamflow projected by the rainfall-runoff model. In the first step, the models were calibrated and validated. Then the projections of water temperature were derived for the historical periods and two future periods taking into account: (a) climate simulations from the CORDEX initiative (NA-CORDEX and EURO-CORDEX), (b) the GR4J rainfall-runoff model and (c) different water temperature models. The obtained results indicate that due to global warming, the stream temperatures are expected to increase by about 1–2 °C for 2021–2050 and by 2–3 °C for 2071–2100 periods. These changes are not uniformly distributed throughout the year. The largest warming in the USA is found in the summertime, in Poland – in spring and autumn. For some months the discrepancies in the projected stream temperature between various stream temperature models are large. Product unit neural network, logistic regression-based model or air2stream occasionally led to projections that differ from those obtained by the majority of models even by 2 °C. We strongly recommend using at least a few stream temperature models for analysing the impact of climate change on water temperatures or the fate of the aquatic ecosystem.