Influence of surface topography in the boiling mechanisms

Abstract

The present paper addresses the qualitative and quantitative analysis of the pool boiling heat transfer over micro-structured surfaces. The surfaces are made from silicon chips, in the context of pool boiling heat transfer enhancement of immersion liquid cooling schemes for electronic components. The first part of the analysis deals with the effect of the liquid properties. Then the effect of surface micro-structuring is discussed, covering different configurations, from cavities to pillars being the latter used to infer on the potential profit of a fin-like configuration. The use of rough surfaces to enhance pool boiling mainly stands on the arguments that the surface roughness will increase the liquid–solid contact area, thus enhancing the convection heat transfer coefficient and will promote the generation of nucleation sites. However, one should not disregard bubble dynamics. Indeed, the results show a strong effect of bubble dynamics and particularly of the interaction mechanisms in the overall cooling performance of the pair liquid–surface. The inaccurate control of these mechanisms leads to the formation of large bubbles and strong vertical and horizontal coalescence effects promote the very fast formation of a vapor blanket, which causes a steep decrease of the heat transfer coefficient. This effect can be strong enough to prevail over the benefit of increasing the contact area by roughening the surface. For the micro-patterns used in the present work, the results evidence that one can reasonably determine guiding pattern characteristics to evaluate the intensity of the interaction mechanisms and take out the most of the patterning to enhance pool boiling heat transfer, when using micro-cavities. Instead, it is far more difficult to control the appearance of active nucleation sites and the optimization of the patterns allowing a reasonable control of the interaction mechanisms and in particular of horizontal coalescence, when dealing with the patterns based on micro-pillars. Hence, providing an increase of the liquid contact area by an effective increase of the roughness ratio is not enough to assure a good performance of the micro-structured surface. Despite it was not possible to clearly evidence a pin–fin effect or of an additional cooling effect due to liquid circulation between the pillars, the results show a significant increase of the heat transfer coefficient of about 10 times for water and 8 times for the dielectric fluid, in comparison to the smooth surface, when the micro-patterning based on pillars is used.