Industrious in Their Station: Young People at Work in Urban America, 1720-1810. By Sharon Braslaw Sundue (Charlottesville: University of Virginia Press, 2009. 278 pp.)

Abstract

Today's young adults take far longer to achieve the markers of adult identity—leaving home, achieving economic independence, and forming a family—than did their counterparts half a century ago. In part, this is due to the extension of higher education, but also to the greater acceptance of cohabitation and premarital sex, the difficulty in finding a job that will support a family, and the increasing acceptance of a value system that views young adulthood as a time of exploration and self-discovery. This book charts a shift that took place in the transition to adulthood between 1720 and 1810 in Boston, Charleston, and Philadelphia. Challenging the view that young peoples' labor experiences were largely static until the apprenticeship system broke down in the wake of the Revolution, due to the erosion of patriarchal power relations and the rise of proto-industrialization, this book argues, instead, that profound, if uneven, transformations took place during the eighteenth century. At the beginning of this period, work, not schooling, occupied a central place in the lives of urban youth, with some young people holding formal apprenticeships, while many others toiled as indentured or informally contracted servants or laborers without any promise of vocational training. During the mid-eighteenth century, the volatility of seaboard economies—as a result of integration into transatlantic trade networks and wartime disruptions—and increases in the availability of adult laborers radically altered employment opportunities for the young. Parents with sufficient means embraced formal schooling for their sons as the favored strategy for strengthening their economic prospects in a shifting labor market, while the indigent found themselves increasingly marginalized in “dead-end” occupations. In the late eighteenth and early nineteenth century North, efforts to intensify agricultural and livestock production and increase participation in the market economy through small-scale household manufacturing, coupled with the growth of new manufacturing enterprises, heightened demand for the labor of poor children and youth, even as apprenticeship opportunities in middling-status crafts dwindled.