Induced morphological defence: evidence from whole-lake manipulation experiments

Abstract

Predator-induced defences are activated by cues associated with predators and confer some degree of resistance to subsequent attacks. Laboratory studies of many taxa have revealed such induced defences, and these data often conform to large-scale surveys of defence levels in habitats with and without predators. However, there have been no studies that make the direct connection between these laboratory studies and field surveys. We conducted a large-scale field manipulation of predators to provide this connection. Previous laboratory experiments on dragonfly (Leucorrhinia dubia) larvae have demonstrated that the presence of fish predators induces the development of elongated abdominal spines that serve to reduce mortality risk. In this study we determine the effect of whole-lake predator manipulation on this induced morphological defence of L. dubia. We monitored the spine lengths of final-instar larvae in two experimental lakes for 7 consecutive years. Fish were present during the first 2 years and then removed for the remaining 5 years. Results demonstrate that the spine lengths of L. dubia larvae decreased significantly in both lakes after the removal of fish. In contrast, there was no corresponding change in the spine lengths of larvae in reference lakes, and we found little change in food supply for larvae. Our results suggest that the plastic response in spine length is strong and attributable to the presence of predators.