Indirect interaction between butterfly species mediated by a shared pupal parasitoid

Abstract

AbstractIndirect interactions among species can greatly affect their abundances and the structure of the community they live in. Using a field experiment, we tested the hypothesis that congeneric butterfly species interact indirectly through a shared pupal parasitoid. We predicted that symmetrical apparent competition would lead to high parasitism of both species, and the effect would increase with regional butterfly abundance. Instead, parasitism of one host, Melitaea cinxia, was reduced in the presence of the second host, M. athalia. Parasitism of M. athalia did not differ whether or not M. cinxia was present. This pattern did not vary with regional butterfly abundance, though overall rate of parasitism did. Details of the experiment suggest that the apparent commensalism occurred because M. cinxia pupae are protected by silk tents whereas M. athalia are exposed, causing locally foraging parasitoids to favour the more accessible host where the two are present together. The local short‐term apparent commensalism favouring M. cinxia opposes the landscape scale trend, in which parasitism increases where butterfly density is high. The outcome of this study illustrates short‐term apparent commensalism, that host suitability can depend on relative accessibility, and that indirect interactions occurring at different scales may be in opposition.