Abstract

In Finland, a post-war expansion of the welfare state was associated with a decline in the use of imprisonment. The 1990s marked the beginning of a more ambivalent era in Finnish criminal justice. How does this turning point appear in the public discourse on crime by political decision-makers? All parliamentary questions and members’ initiatives from 1975 to 2010 were examined with a keyword-based quantitative search, and further content analysis was conducted on data made up of 1589 written parliamentary questions about crime control from 1970 to 2010. The relative prevalence of criminal policy issues rose significantly in the early 1990s. During the same period, the political initiative moved towards the right and the views of the left seemed to move closer to the right concurrently. Although stances became tougher, expressions of leniency were in the minority before the 1990s too, which stresses the significance of the general level of political attention itself. Developments regarding specific types of crime are discussed.
 Keywords: Criminal justice, penal policy, legal history, parliamentary democracy, political parties, Finland.

Highlights

  • an Open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 3.0 Unported License

  • BOZPWFSMBQQJOHGBDUPSTBSFBUQMBZIFSF BOENPTUPGUIFNBSFOPUFYDMVTJWFUP'JO MBOE*OTUJUVUJPOTNBZĕMUFSHMPCBMEFWFMPQNFOUTJNQFSGFDUMZBOECFTVCKFDUUPJOĘVFODFT BOEHSBEVBMDIBOHFUIFNTFMWFT&TUBCMJTIJOHDBVTBMEJSFDUJPOTJTIBSE4JNJMBSEFWFMPQ NFOUTJODSJNJOBMQPMJDZUPUIPTFJO'JOMBOEGSPNUIFTPOXBSETIBWFCFFOSFDPSEFE JO 4DBOEJOBWJB BT XFMM BMUIPVHI UIF DSJNJOBM QPMJUJDBM IJTUPSJFT PG UIF 4DBOEJOBWJBO DPVOUSJFTIBWFCFFOMFTTWPMBUJMF)BTUIFSFCFFOBTJNJMBSEFNPDSBUJDEFWFMPQNFOUCF IJOETJNJMBSDSJNJOBMKVTUJDFEFWFMPQNFOUTJOUIFSFTUPGUIF/PSEJDDPVOUSJFTBTXFMM ćFEFDMJOFPGEFNPDSBUJDDPSQPSBUJTNBOEHSPXJOHFYFDVUJWFQPXFSBSFDFSUBJOMZTPNF UJNFTTFFOBTCSPBEFSUSFOETBNPOH8FTUFSODPVOUSJFTćFDSJNJOBMQPMJDJFTPGUIF/PS EJDDPVOUSJFTIBWFCFDPNFRVJUFDPOWFSHFOUXJUIFBDIPUIFS CVUUIJTIBTOPUBMXBZTCFFO UIFDBTF1SFTFOUTJNJMBSJUJFTBSFCFUUFSFYQMBJOFEBTSFĘFDUJOHDPOUFNQPSBSZQBUUFSOTPG DPNNVOJDBUJPO BOE HFPQPMJUJDBM QSPYJNJUZ SBUIFS UIBO CZ SFGFSSJOH UP TIBSFE DVMUVSBM SPPUT BOE DPOUJOVJUZ "T UIF IJTUPSJDBM DBTF PG 'JOMBOE TIPXT UIF /PSEJD DPVOUSJFT BSF OPUDVMUVSBMMZJNNVOFUPIBSTIOFTT/PSEJDFYDFQUJPOBMJTNIBTCFFOGPVOEFEPOBOJO TUJUVUJPOBMBTTFNCMBHFXIJDISFMJFWFTTPDJBMSFMJBODFPOQFOBMFYDMVTJPO BOEXIJDIJTOPU JNNVUBCMF

Read more

Summary

Introduction

ĆFIJTUPSZPG'JOOJTIDSJNJOBMKVTUJDFBOEQFOBMQPMJDZIBTCFFOSBUIFSFWFOUGVMćFĕSTU EFDBEFTBęFS'JOMBOECFDBNFJOEFQFOEFOUJOXFSFNBSLFECZBTFWFSFIBSTIOFTT" QIBTFPGSFTUSJDUJOHUIFVTFBOETFWFSJUZPGQVOJTINFOUGPMMPXFEBęFSUIF4FDPOE8PSME 8BS*UDVMNJOBUFEJOBTFSJFTPGTJHOJĕDBOUSFGPSNTFOBDUFECFUXFFOUIFMBUFTBOE UIFNJET BOEUIFNVMUJTUBHFXPSLGPSUIFHFOFSBMSFGPSNPGUIF$SJNJOBM$PEFCF HVOJO*OUIFT 'JOOJTIDSJNJOBMKVTUJDFUPPLBNPSFBNCJWBMFOUUVSO"TFMBC PSBUFECFMPX UIJTMBUFTUUVSOIBTCFFOBOBMZTFEGSPNNBOZQFSTQFDUJWFTJO'JOOJTIMJUFS BUVSFPOUIFDSJNJOBMKVTUJDFTZTUFN8IJMFUIFSFTUSJDUJWFUSFOEEJEDPOUJOVFJOHFOFSBM SFHVMBUJPODPODFSOJOHUIFQFOBMTZTUFNJUTFMG TBODUJPOTGPSTQFDJĕDUZQFTPGDSJNFT‰QBS UJDVMBSMZJOUIFBSFBTPGESVHT WJPMFODF BOETFYDSJNFT‰XFSFNBEFJODSFBTJOHMZUPVHI " EFNBOE GPS DSJNF QSFWFOUJPO NFUIPET UIBU QSPNJTFE GBTU BOE EJSFDU SFTVMUT TVDI BT [FSPUPMFSBODFQPMJDJOHFNFSHFE#PUIUIFQPMJDJOHBOETFOUFODJOHPGESVHDSJNFTXFSF UJHIUFOFE$SJNFOFXTSFQPSUTJOUIFNFEJBJODSFBTFE8IBUIBTCFFOMBDLJOHJTBTZT UFNBUJDTUVEZPGUIFQPMJUJDBMDPOUFYUPGUIFUVSO (SBOU SFTFBSDIFS 'BDVMUZ PG -BX 6OJWFSTJUZ PG )FMTJOLJ ćF XPSL XBT TVQQPSUFE CZ 'JOOJTI $VMUVSBM'PVOEBUJPO. #FSHFO+PVSOBMPG$SJNJOBM-BXBOE$SJNJOBM+VTUJDFt ćJTTUVEZMPPLTBUUIFQPMJUJDBMCBDLESPQPGUIFNBLJOHPG'JOOJTIDSJNJOBMQPMJDZ 8BTUIFUVSOJOUIFTBTTPDJBUFEXJUIBQPMJUJDJTBUJPOPGUIFJTTVFPGDSJNJOBMKVTUJDF 'PS UIF QVSQPTFT PG UIJT TUVEZ politicisation JT VOEFSTUPPE BT JODSFBTFE QVCMJD QPMJUJDBM BUUFOUJPOćJTVTFPGUIFDPODFQUJTOPUUPJNQMZUIBUDSJNJOBMKVTUJDF BTJUEFBMTXJUIUIF EJTUSJCVUJPOPGSFTPVSDFTJOTPDJFUZ JTOPUBMXBZTJOIFSFOUMZQPMJUJDBM"UUIFTBNFUJNF UIFSFJTOPSFBTPOUPUIJOLUIBUDSJNFTIPVMEBMXBZTCFIJHIPOUIFPOUIFQVCMJDBHFOEB PSUIBUJUCFJOHIJHIPOUIBUBHFOEBQSPWJEFTBNFBTVSFPGIPXEFNPDSBUJDDSJNJOBMKVT UJDFJT1PMJUJDJTBUJPOJTOPUVTFEIFSFTZOPOZNPVTMZXJUIXIBU+PIO1SBUUIBTUFSNFEAQF OBMQPQVMJTNUIFTIJęPGQFOBMQPXFSGSPNUIFIBOETPGBTNBMMFMJUFPGDSJNJOBMKVTUJDF FYQFSUTUPCPUIUIFWJDUJNNPWFNFOUBOEFMFDUFEQPMJUJDJBOTSFQSFTFOUJOHUIFPQJOJPOT PGUIFGPSHPUUFOQVCMJD*OUIFDPOUFYUPGUIJTBOBMZTJTDPODFSOJOH'JOMBOE UIFIJTUPSJ DBM PQQPTJUF PG QPMJUJDJTFE DSJNJOBM KVTUJDF JT OPU QFOBM FMJUJTN XIFSF EFDJTJPONBLJOH DPODFSOJOHDSJNJOBMKVTUJDFJTJOTVMBUFEGSPNUIFQVCMJDBOBMPHPVTMZUPBOJOEFQFOEFOU DFOUSBM CBOL *U JT B DPOTFOTVBM TUZMF PG QPMJUJDT JO HFOFSBM‰JO XIJDI EFMJCFSBUJPO BOE QBSUJDJQBUJPO IBWF CFFO GBDJMJUBUFE UISPVHI JOUFSNFEJBSZ JOTUJUVUJPOT UIF DJWJM TPDJFUZ BOE QSFQBSBUPSZ DPNNJUUFFT‰XIFSF UIF QVCMJD QSJPSJUZ PG DSJNJOBM KVTUJDF BT B QPMJDZ ĕFMESFNBJOFESFMBUJWFMZMPX*OUIJTGSBNFXPSL UIFUVSOJOHPGQVCMJDQPMJUJDBMBUUFOUJPO UPXBSET DSJNJOBM KVTUJDF DBO CF TFFO BT B TZNQUPN PG UIF EFDMJOF PG QBSUJDJQBUPSZ BOE QSPHSBNNBUJDQPMJUJDT XIJDI*BO-PBEFSIBTDBMMFEUIFABOUJQPMJUJDTPGDSJNF 3 or as the TFBSDIGPSTPDJBMTPMJEBSJUZGSPNQFOBMKVTUJDFXIFOUIFTPDJBMBOEFDPOPNJDXPSMETBSF EFSFHVMBUFE45PUIFFYUFOUUIBUUIFEJSFDUJOĘVFODFPGQVCMJDPQJOJPOJODSFBTFT UIJTJTOPU BOJODSFBTFJOUIFRVBOUJUZPGEFNPDSBDZJODSJNJOBMKVTUJDF CVUBDIBOHFJOUIFRVBMJUZPG EFNPDSBDZXIFSFCZUIFQVCMJDCFDPNFTMFTTBOBHFOUSFTQPOTJCMFUISPVHIQBSUJDJQBUJPO GPSUIFDPOUFOUBOEFČFDUTPGQPMJDZ BOENPSFBOBVEJFODFKVEHJOHUIFQFSGPSNBODFBOE DSFEJCJMJUZPGSFQSFTFOUBUJWFQPMJUJDJBOT "T EBUB GPS B DPOUFOU BOBMZTJT PG QPMJUJDJTBUJPO * VUJMJTF QBSMJBNFOUBSZ EPDVNFOUT FTQFDJBMMZXSJUUFORVFTUJPOTCZNFNCFSTPGQBSMJBNFOUćFHFOFSBMQPMJDZEJSFDUJPOBE WPDBUFEJOUIFBOBMZTFEQPMJUJDBMNFTTBHFTXJMMCFPCTFSWFE1BUUFSOTPGBUUFOUJPOHJWFOUP DSJNFCZEJČFSFOUQBSUJFTXJMMCFFYBNJOFE BTXFMMBTUIFUFNQPSBMSFMBUJPOTIJQCFUXFFO DIBOHFTJOQPMJUJDBMBUUFOUJPOBOEDIBOHFTJOUIFMBXćFQFSTQFDUJWFPGUIFBOBMZTJTJT MPOHJUVEJOBMMZDPNQBSBUJWFćFFDPOPNJDEPXOUVSOXIJDIIJU'JOMBOEJOJTXJEF MZDJUFEBTBXBUFSTIFENPNFOUJOUIFEFWFMPQNFOUPG'JOOJTITPDJFUZBOEQPMJUJDTBOE

Esko Häkkinen
Journal of Scandinavian Studies in Criminology and Crime Prevention
Results
Coalition Party
Toughening legislative changes o
Conclusions
Discussion
QQ o
Full Text
Paper version not known

Talk to us

Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have

Schedule a call

Disclaimer: All third-party content on this website/platform is and will remain the property of their respective owners and is provided on "as is" basis without any warranties, express or implied. Use of third-party content does not indicate any affiliation, sponsorship with or endorsement by them. Any references to third-party content is to identify the corresponding services and shall be considered fair use under The CopyrightLaw.