Incorporating costing study results into district and service planning to enhance immunization programme performance: a Zambian case study

Isabelle Feldhaus,Logan Brenzel,Anthony Kinghorn,Stanley Banda,Masauso Undi,Chris Suharlim,Carl Schütte,Francis D Mwansa,Stephen C Resch,Nicolas A Menzies

doi:10.1093/heapol/czz039

Abstract

Donors, researchers and international agencies have made significant investments in collection of high-quality data on immunization costs, aiming to improve the efficiency and sustainability of services. However, improved quality and routine dissemination of costing information to local managers may not lead to enhanced programme performance. This study explored how district- and service-level managers can use costing information to enhance planning and management to increase immunization outputs and coverage. Data on the use of costing information in the planning and management of Zambia’s immunization programme was obtained through individual and group semi-structured interviews with planners and managers at national, provincial and district levels. Document review revealed the organizational context within which managers operated. Qualitative results described managers’ ability to use costing information to generate cost and efficiency indicators not provided by existing systems. These, in turn, would allow them to understand the relative cost of vaccines and other resources, increase awareness of resource use and management, benchmark against other facilities and districts, and modify strategies to improve performance. Managers indicated that costing information highlighted priorities for more efficient use of human resources, vaccines and outreach for immunization programming. Despite decentralization, there were limitations on managers’ decision-making to improve programme efficiency in practice: major resource allocation decisions were made centrally and planning tools did not focus on vaccine costs. Unreliable budgets and disbursements also undermined managers’ ability to use systems and information. Routine generation and use of immunization cost information may have limited impact on managing efficiency in many Zambian districts, but opportunities were evident for using existing capacity and systems to improve efficiency. Simpler approaches, such as improving reliability and use of routine immunization and staffing indicators, drawing on general insights from periodic costing studies, and focusing on maximizing coverage with available resources, may be more feasible in the short-term.

Highlights

District- and service-level managers play a critical role in the efficient and effective functioning of primary healthcare systems, which often encompass administration of national immunization programmes
All individuals engaged in these roles and responsibilities for the Expanded Programme on Immunization (EPI) at national, provincial or district levels were eligible for inclusion in this study
The Comprehensive Multi-Year Plan (cMYP) guided strategies and activities for immunization implementation as well as resource mobilization and partnerships based on the National Health Strategic Plan (NHSP), but was not linked directly to action plans or programme management

Summary

Introduction

District- and service-level managers play a critical role in the efficient and effective functioning of primary healthcare systems, which often encompass administration of national immunization programmes. Local managers may be responsible for a range of tasks across the spectrum of vaccine delivery These can include responding to outbreaks of vaccine-preventable diseases, organizing national immunization days, communicating with health providers and the public on the benefits of vaccines, maintaining dependable procurement and supply processes, maintaining effective surveillance systems, training immunization staff, and adhering to the most recent immunization guidelines and regulations (Sabin Vaccine Institute, XXXX, XXXX). Given their central role in responding to the dayto-day operations, bottlenecks and challenges of programme implementation, local managers have the potential to enhance immunization delivery by increasing the productivity and agility of programme operations (McKinsey & Company, 2016). Decisionmaking to enhance performance may depend on factors beyond improved data quality and routine data dissemination, such as the capacity and authority of local managers to make decisions as agents within a complex system (Wickremasinghe et al, 2016)

Objectives

Methods

Results

Conclusion