Incorporating cascading effects analysis in the maintenance policy assessment of torrent check dams against torrential floods

Abstract

In mountainous regions, protection infrastructures designed to mitigate the impacts of torrential floods often consist of a complex system of several structural components (check dams). Over time, the efficacy of this system in protecting downstream assets diminishes as the structural components deteriorate. The extent of deterioration is influenced by the interdependencies between the failure modes of individual components, as well as those between multiple components of the system. Understanding and quantifying the chain of failure events, known as cascading effects, is a critical scientific challenge that remains largely unexplored. In this study, we propose a novel approach that employs physics-based models to examine the deterioration of a series of check dams over time, while considering failure dependencies and bidirectional interactions between consecutive dams. The results obtained from this approach reveals that the absence of a downstream dam accelerates the deterioration rate of upstream dams, while its presence serves to stabilize them. We further incorporate stochastic deterioration and maintenance processes using Stochastic Petri nets to support decision-making regarding maintenance actions for each dam, while also considering economic factors. Strategies involving minor operations achieved cost-effectiveness and prolonged satisfactory performance of the dams, with notable impacts from upstream and downstream dam presence on maintenance costs. We illustrate our approach using a case study of the Faucon torrent in France, where we model the deterioration of three consecutive check dams subjected to torrential floods over a period of 100 years.