In Vitro Study of Percutaneous Aortic Valve Replacement: Selection of a Tissue Valve

Abstract

Selection of the best tissue valve is an essential step before percutaneous aortic valve replacement (PAVR) becomes a clinical reality. The aim of this study was to evaluate in vitro three different tissue valves mounted within the same endovascular stent. Thirty stented valves (10 aortic porcine, 10 pulmonary porcine, and 10 pericardial tubular) were sutured within a 32-mm long by 23-mm diameter cobalt-nickel stent. The porcine valves were trimmed down close to the cusps. All valves were delivered with a percutaneous valvuloplasty catheter and placed orthotopically in a latex root that was cast from a sheep's aorta. The roots were tested in a pulse duplicator at a rate of 60 beats per minute and 3.5 liters per minute. The transvalvular gradient, maximum valve orifice area, and presence of central and paravalvular leaks were recorded echocardiographically. Within the limitations of implantation in a synthetic, noncalcified annulus, the pericardial valve performed best in terms of orifice area, transvalvular gradients, and tissue bulk; but four of the ten valves showed a central leak due to the type of stent used. The ideal valve for PAVR should collapse with minimal bulk to avoid coronary obstruction and central and paravalvular leaks. The tubular pericardial valve showed the lowest pressure gradients and was the most compressible, but was more open to manufacturing errors.