In vitro and in planta investigation of succinate dehydrogenase inhibitor resistance conferred by target-site amino acid substitutions in Puccinia horiana, chrysanthemum white rust.

Abstract

Resistance to succinate dehydrogenase inhibitor (SDHI) fungicides has been reported in some rust fungi within Pucciniales. However, measuring the resistance factors conferred by a specific substitution at the target site is difficult for most species because of the difficulty in performing in vitro experiments and the complexity of the binuclear state in these obligate parasites. We focused on Puccinia horiana because it easily forms homozygous basidiospores that are sensitive to SDHIs during in vitro germination, whereas the uredospores of other rust fungi are less sensitive. We identified two substitutions, SdhC-I88F and SdhD-C125Y, that drive SDHI resistance in Pu. horiana. Using basidiospore germination inhibition tests, we measured the resistance factors for six SDHI fungicides in Pu. horiana isolates harboring SdhC-I88F substitutions, wherein orthologous substitutions were most frequently observed in SDHI-resistant Pucciniales, such as soybean rust (Phakopsora pachyrhizi). The resistance factors were high for penthiopyrad and benzovindiflupyr (>150), moderate for oxycarboxin and inpyrfluxam (10-30), and low for mepronil and fluxapyroxad (3-10). The most potent SDHI against SdhC-I88F-harboring isolates was inpyrfluxam, with a half-maximal effective concentration (EC50) of 0.0082 mg L-1 owing to its high intrinsic activity. SdhD-C125Y played a minor, but significant role in increasing the resistance factors (one- to tenfold increases), depending on the individual SDHIs. This study is the first to use basidiospore germination inhibitory tests to quantify the resistance factors for SDHI-resistant Pucciniales. Owing to its homozygous binucleate nature and the high availability of basidiospores, Pu. horiana is useful for investigating SDHI resistance in Pucciniales. © 2024 The Authors. Pest Management Science published by John Wiley & Sons Ltd on behalf of Society of Chemical Industry.