Improving the interpretation of fishing effort and pressures in mixed fisheries using spatial overlap metrics

Abstract

Managing mixed fisheries requires understanding fishers’ behaviour to allow predicting future fisheries distribution and impact on marine ecosystems. A new approach was developed to compare fine-scale fishing effort distribution of Eastern English Channel (EEC) bottom trawlers to the monthly and spatially resolved abundance distributions of commercial species. First, the added value of using species-specific spatial overlap metric to quantify effective fishing effort and improve the relationship between fishing effort and fishing mortality was assessed. Second, based on the Ideal Free Distribution (IFD) theory, the species-specific weights given by fishers to different species were estimated by maximizing the overlap between target species assemblage and effort distributions in October. At a seasonal scale, our results emphasized the importance of cuttlefish (Sepia officinalis) and red mullet (Mullus surmuletus) for the global distribution of EEC bottom trawlers. In October, cuttlefish and red mullet were clearly more determining fishers’ location choice than historically harvested species and also than the overall expected revenue. This is likely due to external constraints such as low cod (Gadus morhua) quota, causing IFD assumptions violated. This study evidenced the importance of getting good insights into spatiotemporal distributions of stocks and fleets to understand fishers’ behaviour and improve mixed fisheries management advice.