Improving the diagnosis of physical illness in patients with mental illness who present in Emergency Departments: Consensus study

Abstract

ObjectiveThe aim of this study was to establish consensus among clinicians in order to produce recommendations to optimise the diagnosis of physical illness in patients with mental illness who present in Emergency Departments (EDs). MethodA list of recommendations was derived from qualitative interviews conducted with 39 doctors and nurses working in EDs in four general hospitals in England. Using a modified nominal group technique, we then asked a selected group of 15 doctors and nurses to take part in a group discussion with two voting rounds in order to decide which recommendations are most beneficial and feasible. ResultsFive recommendations met the a priori criteria to be considered ‘strongly supported’. These included: having a psychiatric liaison team staff available 24hours a day in the vicinity of the ED; developing detailed guidelines regarding intoxicated patients and regarding parallel assessment of patients by both ED and psychiatric staff; and having regular meetings between representatives of both departments. ConclusionIn addition to suggesting specific recommendations, the study stresses the advantages in increasing the accessibility of psychiatric staff in the ED but also identifies challenges regarding joint work and division of responsibilities between them and the ED acute team.