Improving spatial accuracy of urban growth simulation models using ensemble forecasting approaches

Abstract

This paper aims to improve the spatial accuracy of urban growth simulation models and clarify any associated uncertainties. Artificial Neural Networks (ANNs), Random Forest (RF), and Logistic Regression (LR) were implemented to simulate urban growth in the megacity of Tehran, Iran, as a case study. Model calibration was performed using data between 1985 and 1999 whereas the data between 1999 and 2014 was used for model validation. First of all, Transition Index Maps (TIMs) were computed by means of each model to assess the potential of urban growth for each cell. Using the standard deviation, consensus between the TIMs was evaluated. Because the TIMs of the individual models manifested discrepancies, they were combined using a number of ensemble forecasting approaches including median, mathematical average, principle component analysis, and weighted area under the total operating characteristic. The individual and combined TIMs were then put into Cellular Automata (CA) to simulate the future pattern of urban growth in Tehran. The results were evaluated in two stages. At first, the TIMs were evaluated by means of Total Operating Characteristics (TOC), and then a set of statistical indices was used to evaluate the spatial accuracy of the simulated urban growth maps. The best result was obtained by median ensemble forecasting, whereas the LR model showed the lowest level of accuracy. In similar studies, it is recommended to implement and compare different ensemble methods when integrating individual models.