Impostor phenomenon: Prevalence among 1st year medical students and strategies for mitigation

Abstract

Impostor phenomenon (IP) is described as a pattern typified by doubting one's accomplishments and a persistent fear of being exposed as a fraud. These feelings of self-doubt are pervasive along the medical education continuum, beginning with medical students where IP has been associated with emotional stress, physical exhaustion, depression, and anxiety. We, therefore, conducted an interactive workshop with first-year medical students to educate them about the manifesting patterns and risk factors of IP and strategies to mitigate these feelings. The 60-min workshop began with participants voluntarily completing the Young Imposter Scale (YIS) followed by an interactive presentation that reviewed the literature related to IP and its prevalence in medicine. Participants were then assigned to small groups where they discussed three cases of IP in academia and the medical profession. Medical school faculty acted as facilitators and utilized pre-designed prompt questions to stimulate discussion. Students re-convened for a large group report out, where each group shared main discussion points. The session ended with facilitators discussing IP mitigation strategies that can be implemented at the individual, peer, and institutional levels. Participants were also invited to complete a post-workshop evaluation. Fifty first-year medical students participated in the session. A total of 49 (96 %) completed the YIS and post-workshop evaluation. Nineteen (40 %) participants obtained scores on the YIS to indicate a positive finding of IP. The percentage of female medical students meeting the threshold for IP was significantly higher (84 %, n = 41 vs 16 %, n = 7) than male medical students. The workshop was effective at identifying IP and associated risk factors and providing mitigation strategies, with 95.8 % of participants agreeing or strongly agreeing. In qualitative feedback, participants reported that the workshop was “very interactive”, “provided strategies to manage impostor syndrome” and “helped me become more vulnerable with my peers.” This workshop provided a novel interactive and effective method to increase medical students' awareness about IP which can be employed as a strategy to enhance student's wellness.