Impacts of waterpower management on select fish in the Ottawa River, Canada, with an emphasis on lake sturgeon

Abstract

The impacts of waterpower management on select fish in the Ottawa River are examined in this study and are presented in four manuscripts: 1) a systematic review of published literature on water power management; 2) examining potential causes of variation in lake sturgeon abundance among river reaches; 3) community structure and abundance among water management regimes; and 4) evaluating the predictive power of a lake sturgeon habitat suitability model at multiple scales. 1) Three meta-analyses were completed: (i) macroinvertebrate abundance is lower in zones or areas that have been dewatered due to water fluctuations or low flows (overall effect size -1.64 (-2.51/-0.77; 95% CI)); (ii) a hypolimnetic draw reduces the abundance of aquatic communities (overall effect size -0.84 (-1.38/-0.33; 95% CI)) and macroinvertebrates (overall effect size -0.73 (-1.24/-0.22; 95% CI)) downstream of a dam; (iii) altered flows has a negative effect on the abundance fluvial specialists (-0.42 (-0.81/-0.02; 95% CI) but does not affect habitat generalists (overall effect size -0.14 (-0.61/0.32; 95% CI)). 2) Three main stressors were examined to explain variation in lake sturgeon abundance among river reaches: contaminants, commercial harvest and water power management. Results were consistent with water power management impeding lake sturgeon recovery: abundance was significantly greater in unimpounded river reaches; growth rates were significantly greater in impounded reaches suggesting food was not limiting; and size/age structure in managed reaches was skewed to larger, older fish suggesting recruitment was impaired. 3) Variation in community structure and abundance was assessed for 11 fish species among three water management regimes: winter reservoirs, run-of-the-river and unimpounded. Littoral zone benthivores were significantly lower in abundance in winter reservoirs whereas species that are planktivorous for portions of their life were significantly greater. Lake sturgeon was the only fast water spawning species affected in run-of-the-river reaches. 4) The predictive power of a lake sturgeon habitat suitability model was assessed by paired net sets in good (habitat suitability index (HSI)>0.6) and poor (HSK0.3) habitat. Lake sturgeon catch-per-unit-effort (CUE) was significantly greater for adults and juveniles in good habitat however, predictive power of the model was low (r < 0.18). Standard index netting lake sturgeon CUE corresponded with overall foraging component which suggests the model is a good predictor of sturgeon abundance at multiple scales. Resume Les effets de la gestion de Fenergie hydraulique sur certaines especes de poissons presentes dans la riviere des Outaouais sont examines dans cette etude et presentes dans quatre manuscrits : 1) examen systematique des textes publics sur la gestion de Fenergie hydraulique; 2) examen des causes possibles de la variation de Fabondance de Festurgeon jaune parmi les troncons de la riviere; 3) structure et grosseur des populations parmi les divers regimes hydrauliques; 4) evaluation du pouvoir previsionnel, a plusieurs echelles, d'un modele d'indice de qualite de Fhabitat de Festurgeon jaune.