Impact of saponification and silver-nitrate purification on lacustrine alkenone distributions and alkenone-based indices

Abstract

A growing interest in lacustrine alkenones as a proxy for continental paleotemperature reconstructions accompanied important methodological improvements over the past two decades. New gas chromatography (GC) columns were used for alkenone analysis, that drastically improved alkenone separation, especially for freshwater lakes. However, these recent advances are sometimes not sufficient in separating compounds that interfere with alkenones in the resulting chromatograms and concurrently, new chemical procedures were implemented to further clean up the samples. Here we investigate the impact of two clean-up procedures, saponification and silver-nitrate purification, on alkenone distribution, alkenone quantification, and C37 alkenone-based indices, including the U37K index. The silver-nitrate purification modified the C37 alkenone distribution and thus the C37 alkenone-based indices, especially the U37K index, in 6 out of the 9 studied samples by further retaining alkenones with more double bonds. These changes would result on an average error of 3 °C in reconstructed temperatures. Saponification also influenced the C37 alkenone distribution mainly by removing co-eluting compounds, thereby improving the quality of the results. Both saponification and purification resulted in the reduction of the C37 alkenone concentration by almost half. Clean-up steps should thus be used carefully, paying particular attention to any change in alkenone distribution and concentration. Limiting the use of additional clean-up steps reduces the risk of modifying the alkenone distribution.