Impact of Pretransplant Panel-Reactive Antibody Level on Renal Graft Survival in Patients With a Negative Crossmatch and No Donor-Specific Antibody

Abstract

BackgroundPatients with high panel-reactive antibody (PRA) levels before transplantation tend to remain on the waiting list longer when considering cadaveric donor transplantation and have worse outcomes than those with lower PRA levels. This study investigated the impact of the pretransplantation PRA level on rejection and graft survival after kidney transplantation in patients with a negative crossmatch (CXM−) and no donor-specific antibody (DSA−). MethodsWe retrospectively analyzed 513 recipients of kidney allograft treated from January 2009 to April 2013. Those who tested positive on crossmatching, had donor-specific antibodies, were ABO incompatible, or had no PRA level data were excluded (n = 130). The remaining patients were stratified into 3 groups according to their PRA levels: group I, PRA = 0 (314 [80.1%]); group II, PRA ≤50% (27 [7.2%]); and group III, PRA >50% (27 [7.2%]). Graft failure was defined as a return to dialysis, transplant nephrectomy, or death with a functioning kidney. ResultsThe mean patient follow-up was 30.4 ± 4.6 months. The rejection rate was 20.1% (group I, 18.5% [n = 58] vs group II, 23.8% [n = 10] vs group III, 33.3% [n = 9] [P = .053]). The graft failure rate was 21.7% (group I, 6.4% [n = 20] vs group II. 7.1% [n = 3] vs group III, 7.4% [n = 7] [P = .792]), and the 3-year graft survival rates were 96.3, 92.4, and 92.5%, respectively (P = .851). ConclusionsThe pretransplant PRA level was not significantly associated with graft survival in patients with CXM− and DSA−. However, the rejection rate tended toward significance as the PRA level increased (P = .053).