Impact of intertibiofibular graft on the ankle joint: Medium-term radiologic and clinical assessment

Abstract

HypothesisIntertibiofibular graft (ITFG) bridges tibial non-union, but blocks bimalleolar mortise opening, leading to loss of ankle dorsiflexion. The aim of the present study was to assess dorsiflexion loss and to determine whether it was associated with secondary osteoarthritis.Material and method A 2-center retrospective study included cases of tibial non-union, without initial involvement of the ankle, treated by ITFG with more than 2 years’ consolidation. Clinical, functional and radiographic parameters were analyzed. Dorsiflexion stiffness was defined as<10° flexion. Symptomatic osteoarthritis was defined by radiologic joint impingement and/or osteophytosis associated with pain>4/10 on visual analog scale (VAS) restricting walking distance to less than 1 kilometer. ResultsThirty-one cases were analyzed at a mean 7±2.8 years’ follow-up. Mean pain on VAS was 3±2.6. Mean AOFAS score was 62.3±20.5 and mean SEFAS was 28.3±10.5. Mean dorsiflexion was significantly lower on the ITFG side, at 6.6±7.9° versus 15.1±4.8° on the healthy side. There was dorsiflexion stiffness in 26 cases. No correlation emerged between dorsiflexion stiffness and onset of osteoarthritis. ConclusionDorsiflexion was the most severely impacted motion. The rate of osteoarthritis was too low for any implication of dorsiflexion loss to be demonstrated, especially in traumatic contexts. Level of evidenceIV; retrospective study.