Impact of hygiene on bacterial contamination in extended boar semen: An eight-year retrospective study of 28 European AI centers

Abstract

Antibiotic agents such as gentamicin represent essential components of semen extenders in order to reduce bacterial contamination. But antibiotic resistance increases and AI centers start utilizing antibiotic agents which are more potent. Therefore, a shift to preventing bacterial contamination has to take place. In this study, we could demonstrate that hygiene is a tool capable of reducing bacterial load. In order to analyze 1434 extended semen samples and nine specially established hygienic critical control points (HCCPs, n = 828), 92 quality control audits have been carried out in a time period from 2012 until 2019 in 28 European AI centers. The results show the process of introducing a basic hygienic standard in audit 1 (2012/2013) and 2 (2014/2015) and the resulting achievements by means of improved hygienic conditions in audit 3 (2016/2017) and 4 (2018/2019). Within the scope of audit 1, 19% of the semen samples were contaminated with bacteria (cutoff ≥100 colony-forming units/mL). Audit 2 showed a bacterial load of 13.6% whereas during audit 3 and 4 very low bacterial contamination rates were recorded (4.5 and 5.5%, respectively). In the same manner, analysis of hygiene at different CCPs during semen production showed a decrease in all average HCCP-scores (score 1–6) comparing audit 4 to 1. By regression analysis we could show a significant audit-dependent association of the bacterial contamination in semen samples and hygiene of HCCPs. Furthermore, analysis of the odds ratio (OR) reveals that the bacterial contamination of certain HCCPs poses an increased risk of receiving bacterially contaminated semen samples (filling machine: OR = 3.02, P = 0.06; extender: OR = 8.97, P < 0.001; inner face of dilution tank lids: OR = 3.14, P = 0.09). Around 60% of the variance of the bacterial contamination in semen samples could be explained by hygienic conditions at different control points and their interaction with audit period and AI center. Antimicrobial agents are essential to protect human and animal health but excessive or inappropriate use can lead to the emergence of resistant bacteria. As shown in our study, hygiene management can significantly reduce bacterial contamination and is therefore capable of preventing antibiotic resistance.