Immediate Termination of Fibrillation at 50% Probability of Overall Success Correlates with Defibrillation Dose-Response Curve Width

Abstract

Introduction: Issues in transthoracic defibrillation, including waveform shape, fixed versus escalating dose protocol, and low- versus high-energy shocks, can be addressed by examining the defibrillation dose-response curve. We tested the hypothesis that, for commonly used defibrillation waveforms, the steepness of the overall defibrillation dose-response curve, measured as normalized curve width, correlates with the probability of a successful defibrillation being immediate at the shock intensity producing 50% success. Methods and Results: We used 16 isolated rabbit hearts to determine probability of overall success as a function of shock intensity and probability that a successful defibrillation is immediate rather than progressive (followed by several extrasystoles) at the shock intensity producing 50% overall defibrillation success. Two waveform pairs were tested—a monophasic damped sine versus a biphasic truncated exponential waveform commonly used for transthoracic defibrillation, and a monophasic/biphasic truncated exponential waveform pair similar to those used in internal cardioverter defibrillators. There was a close correlation between probability of a successful defibrillation being immediate at I50 and normalized curve width for the defibrillation dose-response curve. Conclusion: Our findings suggest that a high probability of successful defibrillation being immediate at low shock intensities is correlated with a narrow normalized curve width for the defibrillation dose-response curve.