If it ain't broke, don't fix it: evaluating the effect of increased recombination on response to selection for wheat breeding.

Abstract

Meiotic recombination is a source of allelic diversity, but the low frequency and biased distribution of crossovers that occur during meiosis limits the genetic variation available to plant breeders. Simulation studies previously identified that increased recombination frequency can retain more genetic variation and drive greater genetic gains than wildtype recombination. Our study was motivated by the need to define desirable recombination intervals in regions of the genome with fewer crossovers. We hypothesized that deleterious variants, which can negatively impact phenotypes and occur at higher frequencies in low recombining regions where they are linked in repulsion with favorable loci, may offer a signal for positioning shifts of recombination distributions. Genomic selection breeding simulation models based on empirical wheat data were developed to evaluate increased recombination frequency and changing recombination distribution on response to selection. Comparing high and low values for a range of simulation parameters identified that few combinations retained greater genetic variation and fewer still achieved higher genetic gain than wildtype. More recombination was associated with loss of genomic prediction accuracy, which outweighed the benefits of disrupting repulsion linkages. Irrespective of recombination frequency or distribution and deleterious variant annotation, enhanced response to selection under increased recombination required polygenic trait architecture, high heritability, an initial scenario of more repulsion than coupling linkages, and greater than 6 cycles of genomic selection. Altogether, the outcomes of this research discourage a controlled recombination approach to genomic selection in wheat as a more efficient path to retaining genetic variation and increasing genetic gains compared with existing breeding methods.