“I saw it with my own ears”: The effects of peer conversations on preschoolers’ reports of nonexperienced events

Abstract

The study was designed to explore the effects of naturally occurring peer interactions and repeated suggestive interviews on preschoolers’ ( N=96, Mean age=54 months) memories for a personally experienced event, namely a staged archaeological dig. During the dig, one third of the children witnessed two “target” activities. A second third of the children were the classmates of those in the first group, but did not witness the target activities. The remaining children were not the classmates of those who witnessed the target activities, nor did they witness the target activities themselves, and thus served to provide a baseline against which to assess the effects of peer contact. Following the dig, the children were interviewed in either a neutral or suggestive manner on three occasions. Results from a fourth interview by a new examiner revealed that the combination of suggestive interviews and peer exposure led to claims of witnessing the target activities by the classmate group that were comparable to the children who actually did witness these activities. Further, assent rates to misleading questions employing peer pressure and false claims of actually seeing versus merely hearing about the target activities were elevated following opportunities to discuss these activities with peers.