Hydraulic Performance of Howell–Bunger and Butterfly Valves Used for Bottom Outlet in Large Dams under Flood Hazards

Abstract

Floods control equipment in large dams is one of the most important requirements in hydraulic structures. Howell–Bunger valves and butterfly valves are two of these types of flow controls that are commonly used in bottom outlet dams. The optimal longitudinal distance (L) between the two Howell–Bunger and butterfly valves is such that the turbulence of the outlet flow from the butterfly valve should be dissipated before entering the outlet valve. Subsequently, the flow passing through the butterfly valves must have a fully developed flow state before reaching the Howell–Bunger valve. Therefore, the purpose of this study was to evaluate the optimal longitudinal distance between the Howell–Bunger and butterfly valves. For this purpose, different longitudinal distances were investigated using the Flow-3D numerical model. The ideal longitudinal distance obtained from the numerical model in the physical model was considered and tested. Based on the numerical study, the parameters of flow patterns, velocity profiles and vectors, turbulence kinetic energy, and formation of flow vorticity were investigated as criteria to determine the appropriate longitudinal distance. In addition, the most appropriate distance between the butterfly valve and the Howell–Bunger valve was determined, and the physical model was evaluated based on the optimal distance extracted from the numerical simulation. A comparison of the results from the numerical and the laboratory models showed that the minimum distance required in Howell–Bunger valves and butterfly valves should be equal to four times the diameter of the pipe (L=4D) so as not to adversely affect the performance of the bottom outlet system.