Human papillomavirus (HPV) in an Icelandic population: correlation of HPV DNA to cyto- and histopathologic lesions and evaluation of treatment strategies

Abstract

This study is based on 100 cases with cervical intra-epithelial neoplasia (CIN) smears referred for colposcopy and 200 controls with normal smears. The study analyses (a) the frequency of different grades of CIN and koilocytotic lesions among the cases based on cyto- and histopathologic findings; (b) the frequency of human papillomavirus (HPV) among the cases with Virapap/Viratype (V/V) in biopsies vs swabs and among the controls with V/V and polymerase chain reaction (PCR) in swabs; (c) the frequency of the HPV types according to the grade of CIN. Among the cases koilocytotic lesions were found in 98% of the biopsies and 27% of the smears. High-graded smears and high-risk viruses had at entry a positive predictive value (PPV) of 80% and 88% respectively and a sensitivity of 72% for histologically verified high-graded CIN lesions. Both tests combined increased the sensitivity to 88%. The false-negative rate of colposcopy was 3% and the undergraded rate of CIN I and unclassified CIN smears for histologically verified CIN II–III was 62%. Among the cases the rate of HPV positive tests increased with a higher CIN grade. Cytology and colposcopy are complementary for the diagnosis of CIN and the swabs and biopsies for the diagnosis of HPV. Among the cases the rate of HPV-positive tests with V/V was 62% (97% high-risk viruses) and among the controls 5.5% (78% high-risk viruses). Among the controls the frequency of HPV occurrence with PCR was 11.2% and decreased with older age. The therapeutic conclusions are that the high-graded CIN lesions should receive ablative treatment irrespective of HPV typing, whereas low-graded lesions with high-risk viruses should be treated or observed closely.