Human Agency Revisited: The Paradoxical Experiences of Victims of Crime

Abstract

Victims of violent crime often complain of feeling powerless. In some respects this represents a psychological aftereffect of the crime — an experience in which something was done to them against their will that they were powerless either to prevent or to stop. However, focusing attention on the psychological aftereffects of such experiences often overshadows other important considerations. For example, there is the possibility that an accumulation of subsequent social and institutional interactions may serve to minimize their ability actively to cope with their experiences. This paper seeks to address these issues head on by reframing victimization in terms of the interplay between victims' social and institutional interactions, on the one hand, and their agency to cope on the other.1 Following a brief review of the critical literature on victims' problematic institutional positions and a discussion of agency, data will be presented from a qualitative study of individuals who have suffered the murder of a loved one.2 As will be seen, the differing experiences of these individuals in a variety of social contexts have much to teach us about institutional influences, therapeutic ideologies, and human agency.